Suuuper Tender & Moist Lemon Poppy Seed Muffins 🍋 gluten free, keto & paleo

52 comments

  1. Kimberly McGinnis says:

    I just stumbled upon your website while looking for Keto crackers. Lo and behold I found my all time favorite muffin….. LEMON POPPY SEED!!!!! I’m so stinking excited.. Thank you…. thank you… thank you!!!! I can’t wait to make these over the weekend.

  2. Silke says:

    Hi Paola,
    I made both recipes and both are absolutely yummy, my new favourite muffin😆

    One question though, how does your glaze stay white? Mine turns translucent as soon as it hits the muffins (still tastes great but sometimes I am after the visual effects – laugh)….I use Gentle Sweet as a sweetener.

    Thanks for all your efforts, my weekly highlights are your new recipes😊

    • Paola says:

      Hi Silke! That’s awesome to hear! Regarding your glaze, you probably just thinned it out a bit too much… or it could be the sweetener you used. In all honesty I’ve never worked with Gentle Sweet so I’m not sure how it works :-S
      I hope this helped though! xo

  3. Kristen says:

    Just made these today, so yummy! Mine turned out purple, which I think you’ve said is because of the psyllium powder? No matter, the taste is what’s important! After making keto pancakes yesterday (from another website) that were gritty and not that great, I was nervous about trying another low carb recipe. I’m glad I did, these were great! Next time I’m going to double the batch and freeze them. Thanks, Paola!

    • Paola says:

      That’s awesome to hear Kristen! And yup on the psyllium! I use NOW and I’ve yet to have a purple bread (though in all honesty I wouldn’t care too much either ;)!) xo

      • Kristen says:

        Thanks, Paola! I’ve since read online that psyllium husk oxidizes when you grind it and the result is that it turns purple when it’s baked. Some people say if you grind it again before you use it it will reduce the intensity of the purple (but not get rid of it completely) so I’ll try that next time. I did look for NOW brand but I live in Canada and it’s quite expensive and hard to find.

        • Paola says:

          In all honesty I’m not sure, as I regrind the NOW one and haven’t had it turn purple on me (yet!). I think it could also be a batch thing?

  4. Shannon says:

    Hi Paola, I found your website about a week ago and I’ve already made about 5 of your amazing recipes. I couldn’t be happier with the outcome! Thank you!
    However, with this recipe I ended up subbing regular brown flax for golden flax, not sure if that altered things, but my muffins had a very strong flax taste and kind of a mushy texture and they didn’t rise. I baked them for 19 minutes. Do you think it was just the flax?
    Aside from this mishap, I thank you for your amazing site. It’s by far the best I’ve found for keto and paleo.
    Shannon xo

  5. Kaity says:

    Hi Paola,
    I’m super excited to make these but I’m wondering if these are extra large muffins or regular sized muffins? I only have a 12 slot muffin tin so wondering how many of them to fill.

    Thanks!

  6. Cheri says:

    Thank -you for leaving the old recipe. While both are good, I find the old recipe a bit lighter and more to my taste. Best low carb muffin I have ever made- hands down.

  7. Lea says:

    These were so good!!! But mine didn’t rise like yours did. Any ideas what I did wrong? I think I followed the recipe exact! Either way, they are incredible!

    • Paola says:

      Hi Lea! Perhaps the butter wasn’t creamed long enough with the sweetener (can take up to 10 minutes?). Also check expiration date on your baking powder. So happy you enjoyed the taste though! xo

  8. Gabrielle Yoder says:

    In reply to the comment about bakery style muffins:

    To get a better rise have you considered warming the whole eggs slightly and whipping them to ribbon stage? I’m not sure if it would work or but it might, even if it’s outside the realm of most home bakers. I’m going to try that when I do these. Another solution for rise without sugar might be to just add a teaspoon of molasses to the batter to help with crunch and rise. To get the crunchy tops I thought about mixing a tiny drop or two of molasses with lakanto or something to see how that works.

  9. Gabrielle Yoder says:

    I’m really really looking forward to making these! Almost everything I make from you is awesome so I’m sure my favorite type of muffin will be too.

    Do you happen to be in the works for a fabulous bakery style muffin? You know, the kind with the crunchy sugar top that you get from Panera? I just can’t think of how to get that top with anything but sugar and that beautiful rise with a keto or low carb muffin. I’d even be happy to have a little arrowroot or something in there just to have a big fat giant bakery style muffin again.

    • Paola says:

      Hi Gabrielle! That’s awesome to hear, and I’ll always be happy to troubleshoot with you ;).

      On the bakery style muffins, I discovered a couple weeks back that the issue isn’t with the flours but with the sugar. I baked a bunch of grain free muffins with cane sugar for a friends birthday (we didn’t want peeps to get upset tummies from the sugar alcohols!), and they turned out wonderfully light, fluffy and tall. It turns out that creaming the butter with the sweetener only creates about half the air bubbles than with sugar. I’ll be testing next month a bunch of sweeteners to see which one gives the best rise though. xo!

  10. Elizabeth says:

    Can I substitute monk fruit for the sweetener? I love this blog. I love the keto/low carb gluten free options. Thank you!!

    • Paola says:

      Hi Elizabeth! So happy to hear that! I don’t think pure monk fruit would work well, but something like Lakanto (monk fruit + erythritol would). xo!

  11. vanessa lee says:

    These are INSANELY GOOD! My goodness! First keto muffins I’ve baked that aren’t stumps 🙂

    • Paola says:

      Lol that’s awesome to hear Vanessa! So happy to see you’re cooking around the blog this weekend 😉

  12. Dylan says:

    So many positive reviews and responses… makes my unsuccessful attempt difficult to own up to.

    Well, they ended up “dense and oily”. They look like they hardly did any rising at all. Not sure where things went wrong. I used Bob’s almond flour, ultra-dry powdered psyllium husk, very finely-ground flax meal. Went through the steps, the batter looked good… had some nice stretch to it.

    Not looking for suggestions (necessarily), but really just wanted to post so that other failed attempts will know they have some company.

    • Paola says:

      Oh no Dylan! Sorry to hear that! I do think I can help though, as this sounds like the typical case of your butter not being creamed well enough (given that you mention the flours were finely ground). This is a common occurrence in both normal and keto baking- I don’t have any videos on this yet, but a quick youtube search will get you loads of tips. xo!

  13. Terri says:

    Am I missing something? The paragraph under “flours” mentions Xanthan gum, but I don’t see it in the recipe ingredient list anywhere. I plan on making these for a friend’s birthday, and I don’t want to mess them up!

    • Paola says:

      Thanks for the heads up Terri! No xanthan gum is needed anymore, just forgot to remove the snippet 😉 xo!

  14. Suzanne says:

    has anyone tried baking this as one larger cake? Wondering if the ratios will allow proper rise in that format. I love lemon poppy seed cake, and these look like they might fit that bill. Would be a great birthday cake, if so. Yum. With the cream cheese buttercream elsewhere on this site, I’d bet a spectacular combo, especially with a little lemon zest in the icing.

    BTW, your Print buttons aren’t working on your site at the moment…the shares link thing floats down the page and that’s the only link that works. apparently also including the comments button.

    • Paola says:

      Hi Suzanne! In all honesty I would wait until I post a new version that will work as a cake/loaf too (roughly a week’s wait!). And yup, it goes awesome with the cream cheese buttercream (particularly with added lemon zest yes!).

      And THANK YOU for the heads up on buttons, the sharing plugin malfunctioned (in all sites using it!) and it’s causing havoc until they fix it… :-S. Everything should be working again next week! xo!

  15. Judy says:

    Just found your site & am impressed so I’m putting this together now. Don’t have poppy seeds though. For next time, Can I sub chia seeds if I increased the liquid somehow?

    • Paola says:

      I Judy! Just skip the poppy seeds. Chia seeds won’t work the same at all as they’ll swell up and mess up your wet-to-dry ratios. xo!

      • Peter Andolfatto says:

        This is definitely a good point, but if you add Chia seeds last, I have found this is less of a problem.

  16. Devyn davidson says:

    These are fantastic! My batter made 7 huge muffins instead of six but I wasn’t disappointed. The glaze was kinda artificial to me but I just didn’t use a ton on my muffins and it was a nice touch. Definitely love these and will continue to make them!

    • Paola says:

      Hi Devyn! So happy you enjoyed them! The ‘artificial’ taste in you glaze is probably a result to the sweetener your using (xylitol has the most sugar taste, at least according to my taste buds). xo and thanks so much for reporting back!

  17. Peter Andolfatto says:

    Just made these — they are great! I used chia instead of poppy seeds, ground flax instead of xanthan gum, and added 1 tsp lemon extract to further pump up the lemon.

    • Paola says:

      That’s awesome Peter so happy you enjoyed! And thanks so much for reporting back with your subs, always super helpful to others xo!

  18. Ronalyn Hurley says:

    Paloa, you are a genius. I have tried many keto muffin recipes, searching for one as good as my pre-keto muffins, and had almost given up hope when I found your recipe. These muffins are not just “as good”, they are better! I’ve made them 3 times now and thrown away all my other muffin recipes. Thank you!!!

  19. Vallerie says:

    I have just made my 4th batch of these muffins. This is best recipe hands down for a low carb muffin I have ever made. Wonderful flavor with a tender crumb. It’s good without the glaze but so delicious with when you make this final step.

  20. Shehneela says:

    Hi Paola. I just found your website and am already bookmarking all the recipes I want to try. Just checking with the psyllium husks, are they whole husks or ground?

    • Paola says:

      Awesome Allyson! Glad you loved them and thanks for reporting back! I think they’re pretty heavenly too if you don’t mind me saying 👼🏿 xo!

  21. Mary says:

    Hi!
    I have all the ingredients except for psyllium husk. Is there a substitute for this ingredient? Thanks!

    • Paola says:

      Hi Mary! Technically you can sub with coconut flour but the results won’t be the same (psyllium husk really is indispensable for the nice crumb) xo!

  22. emma stein says:

    these are like your orange cranberry muffins right? we made those during the christmas break and they were fa-bu-lous!! might just have found my weekend baking project!

    • Paola says:

      Hi Emma! YES! They’re the same base recipe! So glad you enjoyed those 😉 big kiss and happy baking!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.